This post is way late, but the story's still pretty funny. And Alecia's really been after me to post more, since the last 146 posts have all been from her. Yes, my wife is urging me to spend more time in front of the computer. I just wanted to put that on the public record, as I'm sure it will be worth something later.
Anyway, my 36th (!) birthday was a few weeks ago, as mentioned in the post below. It was a Tuesday, which meant the kids had soccer practice that evening, and we didn't really make any plans to celebrate or anything. Alecia and I agreed a few years ago that we would no longer buy each other birthday gifts, but would instead give each other experiences (e.g. the trip to Iceland for Alecia's 30th last June). And since we were still paying off Christmas debt and waiting for tax and bonus checks, we agreed to hold off on my "birthday experience" for a few weeks. Instead, Alecia and the girls planned to surprise me that evening with a made-from-scratch cake.
Alecia knows I'm a big Captain America fan (hey, I never try to pretend I'm not a geek), so she had the cool idea to bake me a cake in the shape of Captain America's shield. She and the girls worked all day on it, making the cake and frosting from scratch, decorating it themselves, etc. It took them long enough that Alecia was never able to start on dinner, but it turned out beautifully, as you can see here:

Click for larger version.
Because of the girls' soccer practice, I went straight to the field after work, and then we went home afterward for dinner and cake. The girls were so excited to show me what they'd been working on, and I got to see it as soon as I got home. See it, but not taste it, since we hadn't had dinner, yet. To remedy that, Alecia started whipping up some real food in the kitchen while the girls and I hovered over the cake, drooling and eager to dive in. While she was working on dinner, Alecia kept complaining that something smelled like gasoline. I normally don't smell things until people point them out to me, but I could also pick up on the odor. The entire kitchen smelled a bit like gas or some other fuel. We have an electric range, so we knew it wasn't that. We both went around the kitchen with our noses low, like bloodhounds, trying to pick up on the source of the smell.
Finally, we figured out where it was coming from. In the sink were the bowls that Alecia had used to hold the blue and red frosting for the cake. They both smelled strongly. We soon realized that the cake did, as well. Alecia pulled the cake away from the kids' reach (they'd been very good and hadn't yet stuck even a fingertip in for a taste), while we tried to figure out why the cake would smell like it did. I asked Alecia what was in the frosting, and she listed the harmless ingredients. As soon as she mentioned the red and blue food coloring, though, she got a weird look on her face. She dug into the cabinet and pulled out little red and blue bottles...of candle dye.
"Oh my god!" she shouted, reading the warning labels on the little plastic bottles that were eerily similar to the size and shape of normal food coloring. "I almost killed us all!!"
I had bought the candle dye last year when I was experimenting with making homemade lava lamps (again, I admit to my geekiness). She tried to ask me why I'd put it up in the cabinet with the safe food coloring, but quickly realized it wasn't me who did so. Both of us clearly remembered her constantly nagging me to put away the candle wax and other ingredients after my last failed experiment, and both of us remembered me not doing it. She'd put everything away, for some reason putting the dyes in the kitchen cabinet rather than in the hall closet, where I normally keep them.
Alecia, of course, was upset about the whole thing. She was freaked out that we'd all almost been poisoned, but I think part of her was also mad that we had to throw the cake out. Once we were sure nobody had taken even a bite, however, I thought it was one of the funniest things that's happened to us in recent years. And getting my stomach pumped on my birthday, side-by-side with the rest of my family, would definitely have been a unique "birthday experience," right?
The only regret I have about the whole experience is that I still haven't had any cake and ice cream for my birthday, or blown out any candles. But I hope to remedy that soon, as we're still planning a birthday dinner with my brother and friends at some point.
By the way, this is a bit of a tangent, but I wanted to thank my mom for also contributing to my Captain America fetish by getting me a Cap bank for my birthday. It's the first actual birthday gift I've gotten in years from anyone but Alecia and the kids (though my parents and others have been very generous in sending cards and money, and my brother has often treated me to dinner or other events). It was cool to get something personal and thoughtful like that, and I really appreciated it. That, along with the near-fatal cake, made for a very memorable day.